Sister Abhaya Murder Case : Kerala High Court Raises Prima Facie Doubts At Witness Statements While Suspending Convicts’ Sentence

The Kerala High Court on Thursday conceded bail to a Catholic minister and a pious devotee sentenced and condemned to life detainment for the homicide of 21-year-old Sister Abhaya whose body was tracked down in the well of a community in Kottayam in 1992.

A Bench of Justices K Vinod Chandran and C Jayachandran suspended the execution of the sentences of Father Thomas Kottoor and Sister Sephy and conceded them bail subject to every one of them outfitting an obligation of Rs 5 lakh.

The Bench said, “On an at first sight view at the proof as brought up by the safeguard, and not really countered by the indictment, we can’t however deliver the two blamed, as an in-between time measure, suspending their sentence till the removal of the allure.”

The perception came considering “absence of clarification” from the arraignment side on different parts of the case like how the deadly weapon was at first supposed to be a hatchet and later was named as a hand-hatchet in the remand report.

The High Court additionally said it wouldn’t depend on the proof given by a clinical master, depended upon by the indictment, seeing reason for death as he had composed a report saying that reason for death was suffocating and later said that wounds on the top of the casualty were equipped for causing passing.

The Bench was of the view that his perspectives were uneven and “not really honest.”

While the High Court called attention to these lacunae and others in the arraignment case, it likewise named as “unusual” the clarification of the denounced that the casualty had ended it all.

The Knanaya Sabha Pastoral Council secretary Binoy invited the High Court request and expressed that while it was deferred, he was appreciative to God for the equivalent.

The secretary of the chamber, addressing journalists to Kottayam after the request came, said the two convicts were blameless. The secretary got out whatever Abhaya Case Action Council convener Jomon Puthenpurackal said with respect to the case was false.

“Everybody knows how tenable he is and the Knanaya people group accepts the case was created,” he said.

After the request came, Puthenpurackal, addressing journalists outside the court, guaranteed that the CBI didn’t contend the case appropriately in the High Court.

He claimed that a legal counselor not familiar with the case and who didn’t realize Malayalam was brought from Telangana to contend the case for the benefit of CBI and couldn’t answer questions of the High Court.

He claimed that nobody could be blamed for imagining that CBI purposely stood firm that would assist the convicts with getting bail for the situation.

He further claimed that CBI not recording a counter sworn statement for over a year since the convicts moved the requests demonstrates that it presumably capitulated to pressure.

The CBI seemed impartial and neglected to persuade the court not to give any alleviation to the convicts, he asserted.

The High Court request arrived in an application looking for bail documented by them in their particular requests testing their conviction and life detainment by an extraordinary CBI court in the homicide case.

Different circumstances forced on the convicts by the High Court were that for the initial a half year after discharge, the two convicts will report before the SHO worried on each Saturday at 11.00 AM and from there on, on each subsequent Saturday and they will not leave the State without the consent of the court.

To begin with, the neighborhood police and afterward the wrongdoing branch researched and inferred that it was an instance of self destruction.

The CBI assumed control over the examination concerning the case in 2008 and the preliminary for the situation started on August 26, 2019 and many observers turned antagonistic.

As per the indictment, Abhaya was gone after with the handle of a hatchet since she was observer to some supposed shameless movement including the three denounced.

Then, at that point, Abhaya’s body was tracked down in the well of the St.Pious community at Kottayam in Kerala on March 27, 1992.

Abhaya, a second-year understudy of BCM College, Kottayam, was remaining at the religious circle and as indicated by the indictment, she saw an unlawful relationship supposedly between the two convicts and Fr Jose Puthrikkayil following which they hacked her with a hatchet and tossed her into the well.

Puthrikkayil was released from the situation because of absence of proof.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close